Beta readers represent your target audience. They should be regular readers of the genre you are writing. They shouldn’t be reading first drafts; they should be reading something that you have worked on and think is final, though before you get an editor. Your beta reader is helping you get that manuscript ready for edits.
But, what do you do with a beta reader besides ask what they thought? An “I liked it” or an “I didn’t like it” don’t really help you hone your story. (Been there, gotten those answers; they are frustrating to receive.)
Here are 3 questions to give your beta readers BEFORE they start reading to help make the exercise productive. Giving them before they start reading helps them pay attention to the story so they can give you an answer that is going to help you.
1. When did you decide you liked the main character?
Not just did you like them, but specifically when. They should like the character within the first few pages, ideally on page one. If they like the character, then they will care about the character, and that is what makes someone keep reading. Alternately, and especially, if the character displays a big flaw in those first pages, ask when did you connect with the character? A connection can also lead to caring.
If the answer is in the middle of the story, you need to ask why your beta reader liked them at that point, and why they didn’t like them before. These answers can help you craft an amazing main character that will make your audience want to know what happens to them next.
2. Was there a time you didn’t want to keep reading?
This can indicate a couple of things:
- the story got too intense
Again, you need to follow up with why–because these are opposing issues and are fixed in very different (if not opposite) ways. A story needs ups and downs in the plot, small conflicts need to be resolved but the bigger conflict needs to intensify; a reader might need a break from the action (as might your character), or they may need something to happen to push them to keep going.
This feedback can help with pacing and making sure that there is enough plot to make the story a worthwhile read.
3. Did anything not make sense or was not explained by the end of the story?
In a standalone story, this is super important. The main plot needs to wrap up, and any loose ends should be minimal (although a secondary plot left unfinished is always a good way to bring your characters back for another round.) However, the reader needs to feel like the story they just read is complete. For example, in a romance, the couple should be together in the end, or in a mystery, the mystery needs to be solved.
Now, in a series, you need something left open. Maybe the minor or side plots wrap up, but the main plot remains unfinished (this can be seen in a lot of fantasy or science fiction series). Conversely, the main plot can wrap up, but a secondary plot gets bigger, or hints that there is more to that main plot than the characters thought. Something that I’ve seen work well in cozy mysteries is the mystery is solved, but a secondary romance plot remains unfinished. In fantasy, a small quest is completed that fills in the first stage of the larger quest.
You have to provide satisfaction to your reader. You don’t want them so chuck it away and decide it’s not worth reading.
BONUS QUESTION (Maybe you need to ask or maybe you don’t.)
4. Did anything not sit right with you?
This question is especially important when you are writing about a sensitive subject, or your story includes an act of violence (on or off the page), or it includes another controversial element (think bad stuff happening to children.) The answer to this question could indicate that a content warning is warranted (put it at the back of the book with a note at the front that anyone needing a content warning should look there) or that you may also need a sensitivity read by an appropriate sensitivity reader.
The answer to this doesn’t automatically mean it needs to be removed, just that it needs to be reworked.
And if your intent in including this element is to make the point that it should not sit right with readers, then follow up with what does that “not right” feeling make you want to do now? This will tell you if your story is successful in that regard.
Happy writing! and Happy reading!
What are some questions you like to ask your beta reader, or if you are a beta reader, what feedback do you give that helps the author the most?